Skip to content

From the studio

Why my game has no ads

Sandlings costs £2.99, once. There are no ads in it, nothing to buy inside it, no subscription and no account. That was the first decision I made about it, before almost anything else, and it shaped everything after.

Frida and Luna play on iPads sometimes and they try and play these games that look great but you go on them and they’re just simply ads. You can’t do anything without accidentally clicking an ad - many even if you’ve already purchased them!

My daughter Frida asked “but does it have ads?” and she was so happy and relieved when I told her there are none.

I wanted to make a game you could hand to someone, a child or a grandparent, and not have to stand over them while they played it.

Ads don’t sit on top of a game. They change it.

The usual way to think about ads is as an interruption: thirty seconds you sit through, then you’re back to playing. That isn’t the real cost. The real cost is what the game has to become for the ads to pay.

A game paid for by ads earns money when you stop playing for a moment. So it needs places to stop you. A game paid for by in-app purchases earns money when you’re stuck, impatient or a little short of something. So it needs to make you stuck, impatient and short. The timers, the energy bars, the “watch a video to continue”, the shiny thing just out of reach: none of these are accidents. They’re the business model, built into the rules.

Once you see it, it’s hard to unsee. The question every design choice gets asked is quietly no longer “is this fun?” but “where does this make money?”

I wanted to make a game where the only question was the first one.

It matters more when the player is a child

Adults know what an ad is. We’ve had a lifetime of practice ignoring them, and we still fall for them. A child has had a few years. To a child, the button that says “get more gems” is just part of the game, and the game is asking.

Sandlings is made for children and the adults who end up playing it with them. So it doesn’t ask. There’s nothing to buy, no links out of the game, and no account to make. It collects no personal data from anyone, so it collects none from children. Talking to a Sandling is a conversation with a character in the game: nobody else can hear it, and nothing said is sent to us.

None of that took cleverness. It took leaving things out.

What paying once let it be

Without anything to sell, the game got to keep the slow parts. You can pour sand and just watch it settle. You can tip water onto a hill and watch the river find its own way down. Nothing is waiting to interrupt that, because nothing earns money from interrupting it.

It also got to keep the silly parts. In Sandlings, unicorns poop silver, and the little people collect it to decorate their houses. In most games the shiny stuff is what’s for sale. Here there’s no shop. There’s a unicorn.

And it got to be honest about time. There are no timers and no energy. Make as many worlds as you like, play for five minutes or an afternoon. What you discover, you discover by trying things, not by paying to skip ahead.

I just like going back on the game and it says carry on, and you’re back in your world and you see what’s changed since you’ve been away.

What it costs

I’d be lying if I said this was free. Free games get downloaded by the million because there’s nothing to decide. A price, even a small one, is a decision, and most people scrolling past won’t stop to make it.

It also means each person who plays Sandlings pays for it exactly once. There’s no long tail of purchases to make up for a quiet launch.

I still think it’s the right trade. A game should be something you buy, not something that keeps buying you. But it does mean the only way Sandlings grows is people telling other people about it.

£2.99. That’s the whole price.

Sandlings is out now on iPhone, iPad and Android. It’s £2.99 in the UK, about the same elsewhere. No ads, no in-app purchases, no subscriptions, no account.

If you try it, I’d love to hear what your Sandlings did. They tend to have opinions.

Sandlings is out now on iPhone, iPad and Android.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play
← All news